Ibesich Law Firm — Vienna
Case Law: Civil Law
Summaries of selected court decisions on civil law.
- Case LawLiability in Damages of Children Below the Age of Tortious Capacity (Under 14)Austrian Supreme Court 6 Ob 3/26y of The Austrian Supreme Court (OGH) considered the circumstances in which a child below the age of tortious capacity (under 14) may be held liable for damage they have caused where the persons responsible for supervising them cannot be held liable.Read article
- Case LawOn the Issue of Malicious or Willful Damage to a Motor Vehicle in Comprehensive InsuranceAustrian Supreme Court 7 Ob 168/25v of The claimant, as the policyholder, had a partial comprehensive motor vehicle insurance contract with the defendant insurance company.Read article
- Case LawData Protection and Social Online NetworkAustrian Supreme Court 6 Ob 189/24y of The plaintiff is a user of the online platform Facebook (a social network), which is operated by the defendant, a company based in Ireland (Meta).Read article
- Case LawLawsuit Regarding Alleged Damage Caused by Neighbor’s Tree RootsAustrian Supreme Court 8 Ob 3/25m of A property owner (plaintiff) sought damages of approximately EUR 33,000 from the owner of the neighboring property (defendant). He alleged that damage to a drainage channel as well as to the asphalted and paved surfaces on his property had been caused by the root system of trees that had been growing on the neighboring land.Read article
- Case LawMedical Disclosure to a Cognitively Impaired PatientAustrian Supreme Court 8 Ob 65/25d of A 19-year-old patient was receiving orthodontic treatment from a dentist. He recommended the removal of all four wisdom teeth and performed the corresponding surgeries.Read article
- Case LawNo Instalment Payments for Contempt FinesAustrian Supreme Court 8 Ob 108/25b of In guardianship proceedings concerning a minor child, the father failed to submit the child’s Egyptian passport to the courtRead article
- Case LawNo Withdrawal from a Time Compensation AgreementAustrian Supreme Court 9 ObA 17/25b of The works council of a hospital filed a declaratory action (under § 54 para 1 ASGG) against the province as the employer of the hospital’s employees.Read article
- Case LawLandslide in Storm InsuranceAustrian Supreme Court 7 Ob 189/24f of The plaintiff and the defendant insurance company had concluded a homeowner’s insurance contract that included coverage for damage caused by landslides.Read article
- Case LawNo Reduction of Compensation Claims (Loss of Earnings) Due to Emergency AssistanceAustrian Supreme Court 8 Ob 104/21h of The plaintiff suffered an injury during an operation at the defendant municipal association’s hospital when a nerve was severed, resulting in diaphragmatic elevation. In a previous proceeding, it was established that the defendant was liable for all future consequences and damages stemming from this operation.Read article
- Case LawRecovery of Online Poker Losses?Austrian Supreme Court 9 Ob 54/22i of The defendant is a legal entity under Maltese law, headquartered in Malta, and holds a valid license for online gambling there.Read article
- Case LawDeletion of Negative Reviews by Google as a Media Owner17 Bs 119/23h of The issue of lacking legal recourse against often inaccurate Google reviews on the internet is familiar to many business owners, including a pediatrician from Wiener Neustadt.Read article
- Case LawAccident with an E-Scooter is Not Considered a Work-Related or Occupational AccidentAustrian Supreme Court 10 ObS 55/24x of On the morning of February 10, 2023, the claimant was riding an e-scooter from his home to his workplace.Read article
- Case LawDuty to ensure public safety (“Verkehrssicherungspflichten”) when providing an event space?Austrian Supreme Court 3 Ob 218/22p of What had happened? The commander of the volunteer fire department agreed with the defendant municipality that the fire department may hold a ball in an event center of the defendant. According to the defendant’s house rules, which were part of the agreement, the fire department, as the organizer, was supposed to be responsible for theRead article
- Case LawWaiver of right of way when stopping at the intersectionAustrian Supreme Court 2 Ob 32/22b of In a recent decision, the Austrian Supreme Court (Oberster Gerichtshof, OGH) dealt with the issue of waiver of right of wayRead article
- Case LawLiability of a supermarket in the event of a breach of its legal duty to maintain the safety of its premisesAustrian Supreme Court 8 Ob 78/22m of During maintenance work on the cooling shelves in a supermarket branch of the defendantRead article
- Case LawMust driving speed be reduced when children are standing at the side of the road?Austrian Supreme Court 2 Ob 180/21s of In order to watch surfers on the river, the supervising mother (the second defendant) stopped with her four-and-a-half-year-old child (the first defendant), his older brother and his cousin on a little-traveled bridge without a sidewalk.Read article
- Case LawFleeing from the police can be expensiveAustrian Supreme Court 1 Ob 158/21y of In the course of a police stop during the Covid19 pandemic „curfew,“ police officers checked on a group of people.Read article
- Case LawIs a drunk injured person guilty of contributory negligence?Austrian Supreme Court 8 Ob 22/21z of A man was a guest in a pub and obviously drank one or the other alcoholic beverage.Read article
- Case LawDoes an employee under a fixed-term employment relationship have to take his/her vacation during an ordered leave of absence?Austrian Supreme Court 9 ObA 21/21k of The plaintiff was in a fixed-term employment relationship with the defendant from 01.05.2019 until 30.04.2020Read article
- Case LawAbout the scope of a claim for damagesAustrian Supreme Court 2 Ob 88/20k of In a recent decision, the Austrian Supreme Court (Oberster Gerichtshof, OGH) once again dealt with questions of tort law.Read article
- Case LawBereavement Damages in the Event of the Death of a Pet?Austrian Supreme Court 2 Ob 142/20a of § 1293 of the Austrian Civil Code (ABGB) defines damage as any detriment inflicted upon a person’s property, rights, or person.Read article

Consultation
Do you have a legal matter?
Arrange a personal first consultation — in German or English.
4.7/5 · 29 Google reviewsAll reviews on Google